Thus Far and No Further

In the first two years of Manchester Lutheran Church, all five members of my immediate family had a cancer scare. Four of us had to do multiple hospital trips. Three were investigated for a possible brain tumour. Two stayed in a hospital bed. And one had surgery.

It was only recently that it struck me how bizarre this coincidence was, while doing some administrative work that required me to reflect on the last two years—work that happened to coincide with Manchester Lutheran Church’s second birthday.

Given that the reasons for our cancer scares were unrelated, I asked ChatGPT to estimate the probability that this would happen to every member of a family of five in a two year period, and—factoring in the ages of my kids—it came up with an estimate in the ballpark of 1 chance in 50-100 million, or 0.000001–0.000002%.

Now, statistics like this aren’t going to convince anyone that Satan is real who doesn’t already know there’s a spiritual war going on that we can’t see.

And these cancer scares aren’t the only things that have gone wrong either over the first two years of Manchester Lutheran Church. Why? Because nothing that happens is truly random.

A spiritual war is raging all around us. I don’ t know this because I concluded it from statistical anomalies like my family’s string of cancer scares, but because God tells me in his Word. I trust what God says because Jesus died for me. And so, I know that Satan is always doing everything he can to stop the proclamation of God’s Gospel, which is what Manchester Lutheran Church exists to do.

Satan hates me. He hates my family. He hates our church. And he also hates you, the person reading this article, whoever you are.

As a pastor, people often ask me about the existence of evil and calamity they experience. But when they do so, they frequently assume that God is directly and personally causing everything that happens in their lives.

Now, God truly is Almighty. Nothing happens outside of his providence. But that is not the same as saying that God personally wills and actively causes all things.

In the book of Job, chapter 1, Satan challenges God that true trust in him does not exist; by using the person of Job as an example. He claims that human beings only relate to God positively in any way out of a quid-pro-quo relationship of tit-for-tat. Job was a rich and successful man. So, Satan asserts that if Job were to have his fortune taken from him, then he would curse God to his face. God replies like this (Job 1:12):

And the LORD said to Satan, “Behold, all that he has is in your hand. Only against him do not stretch out your hand.” So Satan went out from the presence of the LORD.

Satan attacks Job, which causes him great distress, but he doesn’t curse God as Satan had predicted. And so, Satan returns to God and now claims that if Job’s health were to be removed, then he would curse God. So, God replies again (Job 2:6):

And the LORD said to Satan, “Behold, he is in your hand; only spare his life.”

Notice two things here about the agency of this evil: that no evil can happen without God’s providential permission; but that the active, willful agent of evil is Satan, not God. In fact, God’s providence acts to limit the evil Satan brings.

Many years later, when God himself walked the earth as the incarnate man Jesus Christ, he would say this to Peter (Luke 22:31-32):

Simon, Simon, behold, Satan demanded to have you, that he might sift you like wheat, but I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned again, strengthen your brothers.

Here’s what this means as we process suffering in our lives. I’ll use my family as an example.

For the first two years of Manchester Lutheran Church my family faced a 1 in 50 million cluster of cancer scares at different stages of diagnosis. Why did that happen? Well, I don’t know the specific details of why anything happens, but the book of Job, and Jesus speaking to Peter, reveals that Satan wills and causes evil things like this to happen, whereas God only permits and in fact limits evil happening.

So, the specific details of the battle going on in the heavenly places is unknown to us, but we do know the motivations of both sides:

Satan does everything to try and make me doubt God’s goodness toward me, to silence God’s Word that proclaims that goodness to me, and to get me to place my trust in myself rather than trusting God’s goodness to me in Christ outside myself.

God, on the other hand, is objectively always good toward me, is constantly telling me that in his Word and its proclamation, and in everything is working to encourage me to place my trust in Christ, who died to forgive my sins thus proving God’s love for me.

How do we know these are the motivations of these two extremely powerful beings? We see both their motivations most clearly at the cross of Christ. Here we see Satan entering into Judas to betray Christ and bring about his death (John 13:27), while here we also see the love of God revealed for the whole world (John 3:16).

At the cross, Satan’s murderous intent and God’s saving love are both exposed. Satan brings Christ to death; God uses that very death to save sinners and defeat Satan himself. So whatever may be happening behind the suffering we see, Satan is never sovereign. God sets the limits. Thus far, and no further.