Why am I still such a bad Christian?

15 November 2026
Colossians 1:3-14
Pete Myers

Sermon points

  1. The Gospel bears fruit in you as faith and love for others
  2. God wants you to ask him to give you understanding, good works, and endurance
  3. Because God's forgiveness from outside you produces what he wants from you

Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. Amen. Why am I still such a bad Christian? This week, when faced with familiar stresses and discouragements, the emotions and thoughts that came to me were very familiar. I’ve experienced those responses this year. Last year. And every year going back to when I was a child. Despite now being an adult. Being a Christian. And even having the clarity of the Lutheran faith… it sometimes feels like I haven’t changed at all.

As I spoke to some of you this week, that was the case for you too. Some of us may be impulsively generous without being careful. Some of us are driven by a sense of panic and freeze. Others of us get frustrated or suspicious. And then we act from these feelings in all sorts of ways.

God really does want Christians to understand his will, do good and to endure suffering And yet we remain painfully aware of how far short we fall. The reason confession and absolution is normal in our lives is because we are all, by nature, evil on the inside. Each in our own ways and for our own reasons, we all struggle with this question throughout our lives: Why am I still such a bad Christian? Paul’s opening prayer of Colossians addresses this, by exposing the way we commonly confuse what is inside us and what is outside of us. Paul’s prayer reveals three things: 1) The Gospel bears fruit in you as faith and love for others 2) So, God wants you to ask him to give you understanding, good works, and endurance 3) Because God’s forgiveness from outside you produces what he wants from you

So, first, The Gospel bears fruit in you as faith and love for others

Please look at vv. 3-4:

³ We give thanks to God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, always praying for you, ⁴ having heard of your faith in Christ Jesus and of the love that you have for all the saints.

Paul is always praying for the Colossians, because they have faith in Christ—they trust Jesus— and they love others—they live to serve other people. He thanks God for this faith and love, because they did not come from the Colossians themselves, but from God. Paul explains why and how the Colossians have this faith and love in vv. 5-8:

⁵ Because of the hope stored up for you in the heavens,

The good and mercy God has promised from beyond this world, which came to them in the means of grace, vv. 5-6:

which you heard about before in the Word of truth, the Gospel, ⁶ which is present among you,

It is this Gospel, God’s Word, that bears fruit everywhere, v. 6:

just as in the whole world it is bearing fruit and growing just as also it is in you, from the very day you heard and recognised the grace of God in truth,

That’s why God gives us pastors—to give us this Word, v. 7:

⁷ just as you learned from Epaphras our beloved fellow servant, who is a faithful minister of Christ for you,

Because it is through us hearing that Word of the Gospel from the outside that the Spirit creates love in us, v. 8:

⁸ who has also declared to us your love in the Spirit.

The Colossians have faith and love purely because of God’s goodness. It is as that goodness comes to them through the Word, that the Spirit creates love in them.

You cannot create love yourself. You are naturally selfish. I was talking to several people this week about what the Christian message is.

The Christian Gospel does not bring out the natural good in you. The Gospel gives you God’s goodness from outside yourself.

Growing as a Christian does not mean that I’m suddenly safe from the temptations of anger, sex, theft and lying. Those temptations are already inside me, from my sinful nature. In our Gospel reading today: the girl Jesus visits is dead. Nothing inside her is alive. That’s why when Jesus says she’s just sleeping, the crowd laugh at him—he’s being ridiculous. Life comes to her from the outside, as Jesus touches her.

The Gospel bears fruit in you as faith and love for others

If you want to grow in love, you cannot rely on yourself. That’s why Paul prays for the Colossians.

And so, point 2: God wants you to ask him to give you understanding, good works, and endurance

Look at what Paul says about understanding in v. 9:

⁹ Because of this, we also, from the very day we heard, have not ceased praying for you and asking that you may be filled with the knowledge of his will in all spiritual wisdom and understanding

Paul doesn’t tell the Colossians merely to think harder, or trust whatever seems right to them. Paul appeals to God—outside the Colossians—and asks him to fill them with knowledge of what he wants. And that understanding changes what I actually do, v. 10:

¹⁰ to walk in a way worthy of the Lord, fully pleasing to him, bearing fruit in every good work and growing in the knowledge of God,

Many people say to me: “Despite what I did, I know I’m a good person.” But Jesus said that out of heart of man come our evil works. I can’t create good works myself, because I’m not good. God gives me those good works—to serve my neighbour, care for others, be concerned with others above myself. Paul asks God the Colossians will walk in a way focused on others, because in ourselves we are naturally self-focused. And suffering can drive us even more inward, so he prays vv. 11-12:

¹¹ being empowered with all power according to his glorious might for all endurance and patience with joy, ¹² giving thanks to the Father who has made you fit for a share in the inheritance of the saints in light,

When we suffer, it is natural to feel sorry for ourselves, and think of ourselves as victims. That’s why Paul prays they would be empowered with God’s power to endure and have patience with joy. —a joy that doesn’t come from personality, or a natural disposition, but from the Father.

Suffering brings out what is already inside you. When you suffer, or you’re threatened, or attacked, what comes out of you? Panic, anxiety, anger, frustration, the need to control?

I’ll tell you what doesn’t come out naturally: joy. Something needs to work in you supernaturally from the outside to produce joy in response to suffering.

Paul prays these things for the Colossians because God wants you to ask him to give you understanding, good works, and endurance

We so easily label what comes from with us as good. We defend ourselves, explain ourselves, try to convince ourselves and others we’re good. And if you think you’re already a good person: why would you bother praying for understanding, good works and endurance? And so often we do everything except pray. We read, study, plan, organise and act as though the power were in ourselves. But look at your actual actions, your thoughts, your confusion. Look at your lack of discipline, your natural selfishness, the way that suffering brings out thoughts about yourself.

We all need God to act on us from the outside. 3) Because God’s forgiveness from outside you produces what he wants from you

See how Paul describes the Gospel in vv. 13-14:

¹³ who delivered us from the domain of darkness and transferred us into the kingdom of his beloved Son, ¹⁴ in whom we have redemption, the forgiveness of sins.

Paul doesn’t describe God bringing out the good in you. He doesn’t talk about church inspiring us to be better. He doesn’t refer to a technique or method.

He describes God action toward us as moving us from one place to another: the domain of darkness —where we can’t see God’s love, mercy and forgiveness— to the kingdom of his beloved Son —where we see God’s love and mercy toward us in Christ, where we see the forgiveness has gave us in Christ, where we see God’s good mood toward us in Christ.

This is how it is that God is in a good mood with the whole world, and yet there is still a difference between Christians and those who are outside Christ. It’s not that God is frustrated with those outside Christ. It’s that outside Christ, we are in the dark about God’s attitude toward us. Because all God’s goodness is only found in him.

God’s goodness to us in Christ is redemption: I’m evil, I’m naturally selfish… …but you’re set free from those failings. They don’t define you. They don’t control you.

You are forgiven. The selfish things that have come out of you are forgiven. The sins you committed because you were frightened are forgiven. The anger you defended is forgiven. The words you wish you had not spoken are forgiven. The Father has not left you in darkness.

He has delivered you. You are not trying to make yourself fit for his kingdom. He has made you fit. You are not waiting outside until you finally become a better Christian.

He has transferred you into the kingdom of his beloved Son. And in that Son, right now, you have redemption.

You have the forgiveness of sins. . The message you hear every Sunday is not: Do better to make God happy. It is that God is already happy, because Christ has done better for you.

So, don’t waste your time trying to defend why you think you’re already a good person. Don’t focus on the kind of person you want to be.

Look at God’s attitude to you in Christ, and make use of it.

God’s forgiveness from outside you produces what he wants from you

You don’t need to beat yourself up. You don’t need to set your standards really low so you can achieve them. You don’t need to pretend you’re some kind of saintly super human who doesn’t have flaws.

I can be honest with myself and God: I am by nature an evil, selfish person who will keep making the same mistakes. I can be honest like this, because I lose nothing by admitting this. Instead, I gain everything by continually placing my eyes on Christ: —I am in his kingdom. —I stand under his forgiveness. —I am set free from my selfishness by his redemption.

So, Why am I still such a bad Christian?

Stop looking inside yourself and rating how you’re doing. Because you’ll either come up with a falsely positive idea that you’re far stronger at fighting sin than you are. Or you’ll despair when you see your failure and fail to see the strength that Christ has for you.

It is the Gospel that bears fruit in you as faith and love for others Not positive thoughts. Not inspiring messages that bring out your inner goodness. Not moving music that stirs noble emotions.

God gives you this fruit through the Gospel, and so, God wants you to ask him to give you understanding, good works, and endurance If God did not spare his own Son but gave him up for us all, how will he not also with him graciously give us all things? So ask him! Ask him for understanding. Ask him for good works. Ask him for strength to endure. And when you find yourself failing again tomorrow, don’t ask whether you have finally become good enough. Look outside yourself.

Because God’s forgiveness from outside you produces what he wants from you

The Father has made you fit. He has delivered you. He has brought you into the kingdom of his beloved Son. And in Christ you have redemption, the forgiveness of all your sins. That Gospel is already bearing fruit in you. And it will keep bearing fruit. The peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. Amen.